Discussion:
Transmission problems. What should I do?
(too old to reply)
H Z
2010-08-06 01:01:25 UTC
Permalink
Hi all. I drive a 98 Lexus gs 300 w 160 k miles. Recently while
driving down a very steep mountain the car slows from 75 to 60 mph and
the tach is at 2000 rpms. When I go to give it a little gas the
transmission doesn't respond it can't find the gear it's lookng for.
Eventually the tranny kicks back in and 5 minutes later everything is
back to normal.

How concerned should I be? I've made this 5 hr trip before many times
and this is a first.

I appreciate any input
Mark
2010-08-06 01:56:47 UTC
Permalink
Post by H Z
Hi all. I drive a 98 Lexus gs 300 w 160 k miles. Recently while
driving down a very steep mountain the car slows from 75 to 60 mph and
the tach is at 2000 rpms. When I go to give it a little gas the
transmission doesn't respond it can't find the gear it's lookng for.
Eventually the tranny kicks back in and 5 minutes later everything is
back to normal.
How concerned should I be? I've made this 5 hr trip before many times
and this is a first.
I appreciate any input
Not to discourage usenet use or anything, and this is not meant to
supplant any useful info you might receive from folks in this thread,
but my recommendation is to go to these forums, create an account in
the GS section and describe your symptoms (after searching for
existing threads on the topic of course). You will find a wealth of
info there.

http://www.clublexus.com/forums/
Ray O
2010-08-06 03:17:45 UTC
Permalink
Post by H Z
Hi all. I drive a 98 Lexus gs 300 w 160 k miles. Recently while
driving down a very steep mountain the car slows from 75 to 60 mph and
the tach is at 2000 rpms. When I go to give it a little gas the
transmission doesn't respond it can't find the gear it's lookng for.
Eventually the tranny kicks back in and 5 minutes later everything is
back to normal.
How concerned should I be? I've made this 5 hr trip before many times
and this is a first.
I appreciate any input
When is the last time the transmission was serviced, and what is the
condition of the ATF? What position was the gear selector in at the time?
--
Ray O
(correct punctuation to reply)
H Z
2010-08-06 05:04:39 UTC
Permalink
Post by Ray O
Post by H Z
Hi all. I drive a 98 Lexus gs 300 w 160 k miles. Recently while
driving down a very steep mountain the car slows from 75 to 60 mph and
the tach is at 2000 rpms. When I go to give it a little gas the
transmission doesn't respond it can't find the gear it's lookng for.
Eventually the tranny kicks back in and 5 minutes later everything is
back to normal.
How concerned should I be? I've made this 5 hr trip before many times
and this is a first.
I appreciate any input
When is the last time the transmission was serviced, and what is the
condition of the ATF?  What position was the gear selector in at the time?
--
Ray O
(correct punctuation to reply)
Hi Ray. The car was in drive. I pulled over the next chance to check
the ATF. It seemed a little thin but had a good color and wasn't hot
coming off of the dipstick.

The transmission has never been serviced other than me changing out 2
quarts with every other oil change. Is that the problem u suspect.
Bad ATF?
H Z
2010-08-06 06:11:11 UTC
Permalink
I also thought I'd mention this happened only 1 time on each trip only
while going Down a very steep mountain. The first time I didn't think
anything of it... the second time on the return trip was cause for
concern. I don't think it's a normal condition as it never happened
before during this same route (San Diego to Las Vegas).

Ray has been here for me for many years now. It's an answer I know I
can trust as opposed to club lexus.
Mark
2010-08-06 13:28:51 UTC
Permalink
Post by H Z
Ray has been here for me for many years now. It's an answer I know I
can trust as opposed to club lexus.
I am not doubting the quality of Ray's advice for one moment, but this
is quite possibly the most retarded statement I've seen on usenet in
many years.

There are multiple Lexus engineers that frequent Club Lexus and post
advice for fucks sake! I didn't even say you should necessarily
follow their advice, just take a look and come to your own
conclusions. You will find many people who have the EXACT same car as
you. When you begin to get advice from dozens of folks who have the
exact same year model, you can usually begin to see patterns that will
lead you in the direction of valuable information versus
"untrustworthy" info. I have never seen untrusthworthy info there,
personally. Sometimes folks post their experiences that have nothing
to do with my own, but nobody has ever tried to give me bad advice. As
with any forum, you should never maintain your car based on one
persons advice, even if he is a master mechanic that specializes in
your particular car. What's greate about CL is that you can contrast
and compare a large number of different user experiences and draw your
own conclusions about how to best handle yours.
DaveW
2010-08-06 17:18:54 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mark
I am not doubting the quality of Ray's advice for one moment, but this
is quite possibly the most retarded statement I've seen on usenet in
many years.
Is this your first time visiting alt.autos.lexus?
H Z
2010-08-06 18:37:36 UTC
Permalink
Post by Mark
Ray has been here for me for many years now.  It's an answer I know I
can trust as opposed to club lexus.
I am not doubting the quality of Ray's advice for one moment, but this
is quite possibly the most retarded statement I've seen on usenet in
many years.
There are multiple Lexus engineers that frequent Club Lexus and post
advice for fucks sake!  I didn't even say you should necessarily
follow their advice, just take a look and come to your own
conclusions.  You will find many people who have the EXACT same car as
you.  When you begin to get advice from dozens of folks who have the
exact same year model, you can usually begin to see patterns that will
lead you in the direction of valuable information versus
"untrustworthy" info.  I have never seen untrusthworthy info there,
personally.  Sometimes folks post their experiences that have nothing
to do with my own, but nobody has ever tried to give me bad advice. As
with any forum, you should never maintain your car based on one
persons advice, even if he is a master mechanic that specializes in
your particular car.  What's greate about CL is that you can contrast
and compare a large number of different user experiences and draw your
own conclusions about how to best handle yours.
alright.. i'll try clublexus.. can't hurt
Mark
2010-08-07 00:22:20 UTC
Permalink
Post by H Z
Post by Mark
Ray has been here for me for many years now.  It's an answer I know I
can trust as opposed to club lexus.
I am not doubting the quality of Ray's advice for one moment, but this
is quite possibly the most retarded statement I've seen on usenet in
many years.
There are multiple Lexus engineers that frequent Club Lexus and post
advice for fucks sake!  I didn't even say you should necessarily
follow their advice, just take a look and come to your own
conclusions.  You will find many people who have the EXACT same car as
you.  When you begin to get advice from dozens of folks who have the
exact same year model, you can usually begin to see patterns that will
lead you in the direction of valuable information versus
"untrustworthy" info.  I have never seen untrusthworthy info there,
personally.  Sometimes folks post their experiences that have nothing
to do with my own, but nobody has ever tried to give me bad advice. As
with any forum, you should never maintain your car based on one
persons advice, even if he is a master mechanic that specializes in
your particular car.  What's greate about CL is that you can contrast
and compare a large number of different user experiences and draw your
own conclusions about how to best handle yours.
alright.. i'll try clublexus.. can't hurt
Thank you. You have restored my faith in many things by simply giving
it a try, and you're right it doesn't hurt. You'll read some things,
evaluate them from a common sense point of view, compare their
experiences to what known friends have to say, and ultimately emerge
in a better spot.

I have not really spent time on the GS forums, but I do find the IS
forums very useful. Even though, many of the folks on the IS forums
are a younger crowd who are heavily into modifications, just having a
single point of collection for many owners of the same car is a great
way to see how your experience compares; like I said you'll probably
encounter some folks who are much closer to the brand than the average
car enthusiast and know your vehicle quite well. Conversations on the
IS forum are always civil and (almost always) productive, and I would
guess the overall demographic of the GS forums will be even more
mature, so you should be in good hands.
H Z
2010-08-06 23:03:44 UTC
Permalink
I spoke w/ a Lexus Master Technician today who said that my problem is
that the sharp decline of the mountain rushed all of the trans fluid
to one side of the car and that's why I was having problems only in
that situation. An answer like that actually makes sense to me and
that's the best he can do w/o looking at the car.

His diagnosis was that I didn't have enough fluid. However, according
to the dipstick I am at full. So for now I may just keep the car
locally and avoid long mountainous road trips for awhile.

Does the master technician's answer sound possible?
Ray O
2010-08-07 16:21:10 UTC
Permalink
Post by H Z
I spoke w/ a Lexus Master Technician today who said that my problem is
that the sharp decline of the mountain rushed all of the trans fluid
to one side of the car and that's why I was having problems only in
that situation. An answer like that actually makes sense to me and
that's the best he can do w/o looking at the car.
His diagnosis was that I didn't have enough fluid. However, according
to the dipstick I am at full. So for now I may just keep the car
locally and avoid long mountainous road trips for awhile.
Does the master technician's answer sound possible?
The answer is possible if the ATF level was low, however, it is easy to
confirm whether or not the answer is correct. Under the same exact
conditions, the vehicle will exhibit the same behavior.

To answer your earlier question, it doesn't sound like the incorrect ATF was
used because the vehicle would exhibit problems under a wider variety or
driving conditions. I asked the question to see whether the ATF had
deteriorated, which it doesn't sound like. ATF is much thinner than motor
oil, especially when hot.

In your original post, you said that the transmission didn't respond when
you gave it gas, but did the engine respond?

Your transmission will downshift under certain conditions, and 2,000 RPM
while going down a fairly steep road doesn't sound excessive. If the
transmission upshifted when the grade leveled off and the ATF is translucent
and pink (and the correct ATF is used), I wouldn't worry.
--
Ray O
(correct punctuation to reply)
H Z
2010-08-08 07:46:05 UTC
Permalink
Post by Ray O
Post by H Z
I spoke w/ a Lexus Master Technician today who said that my problem is
that the sharp decline of the mountain rushed all of the trans fluid
to one side of the car and that's why I was having problems only in
that situation.  An answer like that actually makes sense to me and
that's the best he can do w/o looking at the car.
His diagnosis was that I didn't have enough fluid.  However, according
to the dipstick I am at full.  So for now I may just keep the car
locally and avoid long mountainous road trips for awhile.
Does the master technician's answer sound possible?
The answer is possible if the ATF level was low, however, it is easy to
confirm whether or not the answer is correct.  Under the same exact
conditions, the vehicle will exhibit the same behavior.
To answer your earlier question, it doesn't sound like the incorrect ATF was
used because the vehicle would exhibit problems under a wider variety or
driving conditions.  I asked the question to see whether the ATF had
deteriorated, which it doesn't sound like.  ATF is much thinner than motor
oil, especially when hot.
In your original post, you said that the transmission didn't respond when
you gave it gas, but did the engine respond?
Your transmission will downshift under certain conditions, and 2,000 RPM
while going down a fairly steep road doesn't sound excessive.  If the
transmission upshifted when the grade leveled off and the ATF is translucent
and pink (and the correct ATF is used), I wouldn't worry.
--
Ray O
(correct punctuation to reply)
Thank You Ray.

when I hit the gas the tachometer would go up and rev but the car
would stall a bit as if the car were trying to change gears but
couldn't. So I have no choice but to coast until I'm at about 40mph
watching trucks pass me (could be dangerous in the future) until the
car kicks back in again.

I use the correct ATF and the dipstick shows sufficient amount of ATF.
H Z
2010-08-08 09:12:03 UTC
Permalink
Post by Ray O
Post by H Z
I spoke w/ a Lexus Master Technician today who said that my problem is
that the sharp decline of the mountain rushed all of the trans fluid
to one side of the car and that's why I was having problems only in
that situation.  An answer like that actually makes sense to me and
that's the best he can do w/o looking at the car.
His diagnosis was that I didn't have enough fluid.  However, according
to the dipstick I am at full.  So for now I may just keep the car
locally and avoid long mountainous road trips for awhile.
Does the master technician's answer sound possible?
The answer is possible if the ATF level was low, however, it is easy to
confirm whether or not the answer is correct.  Under the same exact
conditions, the vehicle will exhibit the same behavior.
To answer your earlier question, it doesn't sound like the incorrect ATF was
used because the vehicle would exhibit problems under a wider variety or
driving conditions.  I asked the question to see whether the ATF had
deteriorated, which it doesn't sound like.  ATF is much thinner than motor
oil, especially when hot.
In your original post, you said that the transmission didn't respond when
you gave it gas, but did the engine respond?
Your transmission will downshift under certain conditions, and 2,000 RPM
while going down a fairly steep road doesn't sound excessive.  If the
transmission upshifted when the grade leveled off and the ATF is translucent
and pink (and the correct ATF is used), I wouldn't worry.
--
Ray O
(correct punctuation to reply)
Well when I checked the condition of the fluid via dipstick it seemed
ok but on a closer inspection I may have solved my own question.
Please visit the following page.

Loading Image...

The first glass is fresh ATF fluid w/ a cranberry juice type color.
The second is ATF as it came out of the car. It had more of a grape
juice color. At the same time fresh motor oil looks much different
than motor oil that's been used even just a couple of times. From
what I remember fresh motor oil is a honey color but after just a
little bit of use it turns black right away.

Ray, can you confirm that the condition of the ATF is so bad that it
is likely causing the problem or could it be something else? I feel
like I should be worrying because this is a new situation that has
never happened before.

Thanks much..
Ray O
2010-08-08 15:42:21 UTC
Permalink
Post by Ray O
Post by H Z
I spoke w/ a Lexus Master Technician today who said that my problem is
that the sharp decline of the mountain rushed all of the trans fluid
to one side of the car and that's why I was having problems only in
that situation. An answer like that actually makes sense to me and
that's the best he can do w/o looking at the car.
His diagnosis was that I didn't have enough fluid. However, according
to the dipstick I am at full. So for now I may just keep the car
locally and avoid long mountainous road trips for awhile.
Does the master technician's answer sound possible?
The answer is possible if the ATF level was low, however, it is easy to
confirm whether or not the answer is correct. Under the same exact
conditions, the vehicle will exhibit the same behavior.
To answer your earlier question, it doesn't sound like the incorrect ATF was
used because the vehicle would exhibit problems under a wider variety or
driving conditions. I asked the question to see whether the ATF had
deteriorated, which it doesn't sound like. ATF is much thinner than motor
oil, especially when hot.
In your original post, you said that the transmission didn't respond when
you gave it gas, but did the engine respond?
Your transmission will downshift under certain conditions, and 2,000 RPM
while going down a fairly steep road doesn't sound excessive. If the
transmission upshifted when the grade leveled off and the ATF is translucent
and pink (and the correct ATF is used), I wouldn't worry.
--
Ray O
(correct punctuation to reply)
Well when I checked the condition of the fluid via dipstick it seemed
ok but on a closer inspection I may have solved my own question.
Please visit the following page.

http://www.handogg.com/atf.jpg

The first glass is fresh ATF fluid w/ a cranberry juice type color.
The second is ATF as it came out of the car. It had more of a grape
juice color. At the same time fresh motor oil looks much different
than motor oil that's been used even just a couple of times. From
what I remember fresh motor oil is a honey color but after just a
little bit of use it turns black right away.

Ray, can you confirm that the condition of the ATF is so bad that it
is likely causing the problem or could it be something else? I feel
like I should be worrying because this is a new situation that has
never happened before.

Thanks much..

********
In your previous post, you mentioned that when you hit the gas, the
tachometer would indicate an increase in engine RPM but that the car would
"stall" a bit.

The computer that controls the transmission looks at inputs from several
sensors to determine which gear the transmission should be in, and whether
or not the torque converter should be locked or unlocked. Among the inputs
are vehicle speed, throttle position and whether or not the brakes are
applied, and from the various inputs, the computer infers whether the driver
is trying to accelerate, cruise, coast, or whether the vehicle is going down
a long incline.

Unfortunately, I cannot conform that the condition of the ATF in the photo
is so bad that it is likely causing the problem, but if there is enough
contaminants that the fluid is opaque, it is a good idea to change it. Does
the used ATF have a burnt toast smell or smell significantly different from
the fresh ATF? If so, the ATF needs replacement.

Automatic transmissions have numerous internal clutch packs, and the
friction surfaces wear just like the friction surface on brakes or on a
manual transmission clutch. ATF becomes dark because it becomes
contaminated with the worn friction material, kind of like how a car's
wheels become dirty from brake dust material. Eventually, the contaminants
in the ATF will affect the movement of spool valves, solenoids, and how the
friction materials act enough so that the transmission doesn't shift or hold
gears properly.

Judging from the color of the used ATF, I would change it but do not have
the transmission flushed because flushing a high mileage transmission tends
to cause problems.
--
Ray O
(correct punctuation to reply)
Virgil Skankman
2010-08-06 16:05:39 UTC
Permalink
Post by H Z
Hi all. I drive a 98 Lexus gs 300 w 160 k miles. Recently while
driving down a very steep mountain the car slows from 75 to 60 mph and
the tach is at 2000 rpms. When I go to give it a little gas the
transmission doesn't respond it can't find the gear it's lookng for.
Eventually the tranny kicks back in and 5 minutes later everything is
back to normal.
How concerned should I be? I've made this 5 hr trip before many times
and this is a first.
I appreciate any input
Your car slows from 75 to 60 down a very steep mountain? I suggest selling
your car and getting a bus pass. You're dangerous.
H Z
2010-08-06 18:28:30 UTC
Permalink
Post by H Z
Hi all. I drive a 98 Lexus gs 300 w 160 k miles. Recently while
driving down a very steep mountain the car slows from 75 to 60 mph and
the tach is at 2000 rpms. When I go to give it a little gas the
transmission doesn't respond it can't find the gear it's lookng for.
Eventually the tranny kicks back in and 5 minutes later everything is
back to normal.
How concerned should I be? I've made this 5 hr trip before many times
and this is a first.
I appreciate any input
Your car slows from 75 to 60 down a very steep mountain?  I suggest selling
your car and getting a bus pass.  You're dangerous.
I slow the car by letting off of the gas due to traffic..
Dweezel AnalRetentive
2010-08-06 20:40:59 UTC
Permalink
Post by H Z
Post by Virgil Skankman
Post by H Z
Hi all. I drive a 98 Lexus gs 300 w 160 k miles. Recently while
driving down a very steep mountain the car slows from 75 to 60 mph and
the tach is at 2000 rpms. When I go to give it a little gas the
transmission doesn't respond it can't find the gear it's lookng for.
Eventually the tranny kicks back in and 5 minutes later everything is
back to normal.
How concerned should I be? I've made this 5 hr trip before many times
and this is a first.
I appreciate any input
Your car slows from 75 to 60 down a very steep mountain? I suggest selling
your car and getting a bus pass. You're dangerous.
I slow the car by letting off of the gas due to traffic..
So you slow the car going down a very steep mountain by letting off the gas,
doing 75. You certainly should not be driving. Take the bus.
Wayne
2010-08-07 14:42:42 UTC
Permalink
Post by Virgil Skankman
Post by H Z
Hi all. I drive a 98 Lexus gs 300 w 160 k miles. Recently while
driving down a very steep mountain the car slows from 75 to 60 mph and
the tach is at 2000 rpms. When I go to give it a little gas the
transmission doesn't respond it can't find the gear it's lookng for.
Eventually the tranny kicks back in and 5 minutes later everything is
back to normal.
How concerned should I be? I've made this 5 hr trip before many times
and this is a first.
I appreciate any input
Your car slows from 75 to 60 down a very steep mountain? I suggest
selling your car and getting a bus pass. You're dangerous.
Depends on the mountain, dude. Don't know where the OP lives, but here in
CA we have freeways that go down a mountain. We also have roads like the
Tioga Pass that would be suicide at 75.
Loading...